Walk into a century home in Toronto and the walls feel different — solid, a little uneven, cool to the touch. Walk into a newer home and the walls feel flat and hollow. The difference is plaster versus drywall, and knowing which one your home has changes how repairs, renovations and even hanging a shelf are done. We are a general contractor serving Toronto, Mississauga, Oakville and Burlington, with 11 years of experience, licensed & insured with $2M liability. Nacho and Milu organize and coordinate every project, and all trades are done by licensed specialists.
The simplest test is a knock. Drywall sounds hollow and gives a little when you press it; plaster sounds solid and does not flex. Look at the thickness of the wall at a doorway or an outlet — plaster walls are usually thicker. In an older home, you may also see the clues in the finish: gentle waves and small imperfections in plaster, versus the dead-flat surface of drywall.
Age is the other clue. Many Toronto homes built before the middle of the last century were finished in plaster over wood lath — thin strips of wood nailed to the studs, with plaster pushed through the gaps to form keys that hold it in place. Homes built later were finished in drywall: gypsum panels screwed to the studs, taped and mudded at the seams.
Plaster is hard, dense and durable. It resists dents better than drywall, blocks sound better, and gives an old house its solid feel. A plaster wall that has lasted a century has already proved itself. Its weaknesses show with age: the keys can break, leaving sections that sag or sound hollow; hairline cracks appear as the house moves; and repairs take more skill, because matching a plaster finish is not the same as patching drywall.
Plaster also hides surprises. Behind it can be old wiring, no insulation, or framing that does not match modern spacing. That is why opening a plaster wall in a renovation is always a moment of discovery — and why the work should be planned with the whole project, not as a surprise in the middle of it.
Drywall is faster to install, easier to repair, and gives a flatter finish. A damaged section can be cut out and replaced in a day, and the seams disappear when the taping is done well. Its weaknesses are the mirror image of plaster: it dents easily, it does not block sound as well, and it is badly hurt by water — a leak that plaster might survive can ruin a drywall ceiling.
In a renovation, drywall is the standard for new walls, new rooms and replaced sections. It is the material our specialists work with when a wall is rebuilt or a layout changes, and it is finished — taped, mudded, sanded and painted — as part of the build.
Small plaster cracks can be repaired in place: the loose material is removed, the crack is filled and the surface is skimmed smooth. A large section that has come away from the lath, or a wall with cracks everywhere, is often better replaced with drywall — the old plaster comes down, the framing is checked, and new drywall goes up. The result is a flat, paintable wall that matches the rest of a renovated home.
One honest note: replacing plaster with drywall changes the feel of a wall — it will sound more hollow and feel less solid. In a full renovation that trade-off is usually worth it, because the new wall is straight, insulated if needed, and ready for a clean paint finish. In a single room, keeping and repairing the plaster may be the better choice. That is a decision for the design phase, when the whole project is being planned.
If your home has plaster, say so at the site visit. It affects how walls are opened, how repairs are priced, and what the finished surface will look like. A renovation in a plaster home is not harder — it is just different, and it needs a contractor who plans for it instead of discovering it halfway through demolition.
Our process is built for that: the site visit is where the walls are looked at, the design phase is where the decisions are made — keep the plaster, repair it, or replace it with drywall — and construction follows the plan. The work is done by licensed specialists, coordinated by us, so the plaster work, the drywall work and the painting all happen in the right order.
Message us on WhatsApp at (416) 706-3577 for a free renovation quote
Tell us about your home — its age and what you want to change — and we will walk you through the six stages. Now booking January 2027.